After repeal fails, 'task remains' to reform health care, says bishop

IMAGE: CNS photo/Aaron P. Bernstein, Reuters


WASHINGTON (CNS) — After the Senate Republicans failed to
get enough votes to pass a “skinny” repeal to remove parts of the
Affordable Care Act in the early hours of July 28, the U.S. Catholic Church’s lead spokesman on the issue said the
“task of reforming the health care system still remains.”

The nation’s system under the Affordable Care Act “is
not financially sustainable” and “lacks full Hyde protections and
conscience rights,” said Bishop Frank J. Dewane of Venice, Florida,
chairman of the U.S. Conference of Catholic Bishops’ Committee on Domestic
Justice and Human Development.

It also “is inaccessible to many immigrants,” he
said in a statement.

“Inaction will result in harm for too many
people,” Bishop Dewane added.

The failed repeal bill was a pared-down version of earlier
bills. It would have repealed both the individual mandate that says all
Americans must buy health insurance or pay a penalty and the requirement all
large employers offer health insurance to their workers. It would have expanded
health savings accounts, delayed a tax on medical devices and increased funding
for community health centers by taking defunding Planned Parenthood by $400 million.

The vote was 51 against, and 49 in favor. All the Democrats
voted “no.” Sen. John McCain, R-Arizona, joined two other GOP
senators in rejecting the measure, Sens. Lisa Murkowski of Alaska and Susan
Collins of Maine.

Majority Leader Mitch McConnell, R-Kentucky, had pushed the
latest version forward in hopes it would be passed and lead to a conference
with the House, which May 4 passed the American Health Care Act to replace the
ACA, to hammer out a compromise measure.

The Senate vote is over, but the need to reform health care
remains, said Bishop Dewane, who urged the two political parties to get past
their divisions and work for “the common good.”

“A moment has opened for Congress, and indeed all
Americans, to set aside party and personal political interest and pursue the
common good of our nation and its people, especially the most vulnerable,”
he said.

He laid out four action items he said are essential to any
bill to be considered in the future:

— “Protect the Medicaid program from changes that
would harm millions of struggling Americans.”

— “Protect the safety net from any other changes that
harm the poor, immigrants, or any others at the margins.”

— “Address the real probability of collapsing
insurance markets and the corresponding loss of genuine affordability for those
with limited means.”

— “Provide full Hyde Amendment provisions and
much-needed conscience protections.”

“The greatness of our country is not measured by the
well-being of the powerful but how we have cared for the ‘least of
these,'” Bishop Dewane said. “Congress can and should pass health
care legislation that lives up to that greatness.”

In response to the Senate’s July 28 vote, Sister Carol
Keehan, a Daughter of Charity and president and CEO of the Catholic Health
Association, said her organization is “pleased and relieved that we will
now have an opportunity to work together in a bipartisan way to improve the

In a July 28 statement, she said the CHA “looks forward to working with all the members of Congress and
the administration in the process moving forward and will continue our efforts
to protect and improve the Medicaid program.”

Jim Sedlak, executive director of the American Life League,
was disappointed in the final vote. He said in a July 28 statement that he hopes
the House and the Senate would “put politics aside and pass a simple bill
to take all taxpayer money away from Planned Parenthood. “

Sister Simone Campbell, a Sister of Social Service and
executive director of Network, a Catholic social justice lobbying organization,
personally delivered a letter to U.S. senators July 24 signed by 7,150 U.S.
women religious urging the senators to reject the Better Care Reconciliation
Act and any proposals that would repeal the Affordable Care Act or cut Medicaid.

After the Senate failed to repeal its health care reform
legislation July 28, Sister Campbell said she was relieved for the sake of all the
people she knew “who were terrified that their health care would be taken

“The road ahead is not likely to be straight or easy,
but we must work together to improve health care for our people,” she said.

On July 26, when senators rejected a repeal-only proposal of
the Affordable Care Act, Students for Life said the senators who voted against
it blocked defunding of Planned Parenthood and removing taxpayer funding for
abortion. “There is still a long way to go in this process and pro-lifers
everywhere are going to work even harder to make sure our voices are heard,”
the group said.

– – –

Copyright © 2017 Catholic News Service/U.S. Conference of Catholic Bishops. All rights reserved. Republishing or redistributing of CNS content, including by framing or similar means without prior permission, is prohibited. You may link to stories on our public site. This copy is for your personal, non-commercial use only. To request permission for republishing or redistributing of CNS content, please contact permissions at

Original Article