Citizenship question for 2020 census prompts strong criticism, lawsuits

IMAGE: CNS photo/Shannon Stapleton, Reuters

By Steve Larkin

(CNS) — A U.S. Commerce Department decision that a question about
citizenship status be included on the 2020 census has its fair share of critics and
has prompted lawsuits.

The critics
say such questions might make people less likely to participate in the census,
especially members of immigrant communities.

faith community has powerfully spoken up against the unjust, dangerous addition
of a citizenship question to the 2020 census. Everyone counts, and faith
leaders are organizing to make sure our government recognizes this,” said Sara
Benitez, the organizing director of Faith in Public Life.

Census Bureau set about adding this question in response to a letter from the
Department of Justice. The DOJ said it wants to ask everyone living in the
United States whether they are citizens to help it enforce the Voting Rights

delegated to the U.S. Commerce secretary the authority to determine questions to
be asked on the decennial census. Regarding the citizenship question, the Trump
administration considers the proposal as reinstating the citizenship question,
not adding, what was on the census for decades

department (DOJ) needs a reliable calculation of the citizen voting-age
population in localities where voting rights violations are alleged or
suspected … the decennial census questionnaire is the most appropriate vehicle
for collecting that data,” the DOJ letter says.

the citizenship data is important because “multiple federal courts of appeals
have held that, where citizenship rates are at issue in a vote-dilution case,
citizen voting-age population is the proper metric for determining whether a
racial group could constitute a majority in a single-member district,”
according to the letter.

letter admits that the DOJ can get some of this information from the American
Community Survey, which is sent to about 300,000 households each month and
collects far more information than the census, but the DOJ believes that this
survey’s data is not precise enough. In addition, the DOJ wants the data from
the Census used in redistricting to be the same data used in enforcing the
Voting Rights Act with regard to those districts.

critics of the proposal include the Leadership Conference on Civil and Human Rights,
which said in an open letter to Commerce Secretary Wilbur Ross that
“adding a new citizenship question to the 2020 census would destroy any chance
for an accurate count, discard years of careful research and increase costs

addition, many states, cities, towns, and other organizations are bringing
lawsuits against the Trump administration in an attempt to keep the citizenship
question from the census.

lawsuit brought by Xavier Becerra, California’s attorney general, says that
“the state of California, in particular, stands to lose if the citizenship
question is included on the 2020 census. … Under-counting the sizeable number of
Californian noncitizens and their citizen relatives will imperil the state’s
fair share of congressional seats and Electoral College electors and will cost
the state billions of dollars in federal funding over the next decade.”

a public comment period, which closed recently, the Census Bureau received more
than 39,000 comments about the citizenship question.

U.S. Census Bureau memo noted that Center for Survey Measurement research has “noticed
a recent increase in respondents spontaneously expressing concerns about
confidentiality” and that Spanish-speaking focus groups “brought up immigration
raids, fear of government, and fear of deportation.”

and Chinese-speaking focus groups expressed similar fears. Members of all
groups recommended that the Census Bureau make it clear that none of the data
it collected would be shared with U.S. Immigration and Customs Enforcement or
other law enforcement agencies.

U.S. census is established in Article I Section 2 of the Constitution, which
reads in part:

actual enumeration shall be made within three years after the first meeting of
the Congress of the United States, and within every subsequent term of 10 years, in such manner as they shall by law direct.”

time, the census has added more questions. The first census, conducted in 1790,
asked for only the name of the head of each household, the number of free white
males above and below 16, the number of free white women, the number of other
free persons and the number of slaves.

most recent census, conducted in 2010, asked four questions about the household
and six about each individual person part of the household. It was, however,
shorter than the long form of censuses from 1940 through 2000.

long-form census, which was sent to one in six households, has been replaced by
the American Community Survey.

question about citizenship is not new on the census, although it has not been
asked since 1950.

1820 and 1830 censuses asked about the number of foreigners not naturalized in
each household, and the 1870 census and all censuses from 1890 to 1950 asked
about each person’s naturalization status.

– – –

Copyright © 2018 Catholic News Service/U.S. Conference of Catholic Bishops. All rights reserved. Republishing or redistributing of CNS content, including by framing or similar means without prior permission, is prohibited. You may link to stories on our public site. This copy is for your personal, non-commercial use only. To request permission for republishing or redistributing of CNS content, please contact permissions at

Original Article