Cardinal confirms some priests decline appointment as bishop

By Cindy Wooden

VATICAN CITY (CNS) — Although the number is not high, it is
no longer “exceptional” to have priests turn down an appointment as
bishop, said Canadian Cardinal Marc Ouellet, prefect of the Congregation for

Speaking Feb. 1 about the annual course his office sponsors
for new bishops, the cardinal was asked about rumors that more and more priests
are saying they do not want to be a bishop and declining an appointment even
when the pope, on the recommendation of Cardinal Ouellet’s office, has chosen

“Yes, that’s true. Nowadays you have people who do not
accept the appointment,” he said, adding that he would not provide
statistics on how often it happens, although he insisted the number was not

Priests decline for a variety of reasons, Cardinal Ouellet
said, pointing to the example of a priest who was chosen, but then informed the
congregation that he had cancer and had not told others of his illness.
“It was a sign of responsibility not to accept the appointment,” he

Others decline because of something in their past or because
they think they cannot handle the responsibility, he said. In the latter case,
he said, “normally we insist” because often people are not the best
judges of their own abilities. But when a person makes “a decision in
conscience,” the Vatican respects that.

As for the type of priests Pope Francis and the congregation
are looking for as candidates, Cardinal Ouellet said the pope “has
insisted on the pastoral quality of the bishops. That’s very clear. It does not
mean that they do not have to be masters of the faith because a bishops is,
first and foremost, the first teacher of the faith in his diocese.”

“But the capacity to relate to people, to establish
dialogue, to start from the point where people are — this is a quality that is
also requested,” the cardinal said.

Pope Francis’ “charism is to be very compassionate,
very close to people, but at the same time, he knows where he leads people: to
our Lord Jesus Christ,” he said.

Cardinal Ouellet also confirmed that since at least 2010, the
confidential questionnaire sent to local bishops and priests asking about a
potential candidate for bishop includes a question about whether the potential
candidate ever was in a position of having to handle an accusation of clerical
sexual abuse made against another priest or church worker.

“We have to be able to verify that he is able to handle
these cases well, that is to say, he does not have a mentality of covering them
up or not reporting them or not taking them seriously,” the cardinal said.
As far as possible, the Vatican wants to know a potential bishop will take
accusations seriously and deal with them appropriately.

Since 2001, all newly ordained bishops serving in dioceses
that report to the Congregation for Bishops have been obliged to come to Rome
in September for an eight- or nine-day course for new bishops. More recently,
the Congregation for Eastern Churches has co-sponsored the course and brought
new Eastern-rite bishops to Rome for it. Every two years, new bishops in
mission territories have a similar course sponsored by the Congregation for the
Evangelization of Peoples with some of the sessions overlapping.

The speeches, homilies and reflections from the September
2015 course were published recently in a book, “Witnesses of the Risen
One.” Cardinal Ouellet said he hoped publishing the papers would help
bishops in their ministry as well as elicit suggestions for improving the

More than 1,500 bishops have participated in the past 14
years, he said. While it includes sessions on finances, rapport with one’s
priests and on preventing clerical sexual abuse, most participants say the most
valuable part of the course was the opportunity to meet, discuss and pray with
bishops from around the world.

“The goal of these meetings is to learn their new
identity — that they belong to the college of the successors of the
apostles,” Cardinal Ouellet said. “It’s an extraordinary moment of
conversion for them.”

“A priest who is ordained a bishop comes to Rome to
learn that from now on he has a universal responsibility as a member of this
college,” the cardinal said.

The new bishops, he said, also are excited to meet the pope
who appointed them.

“Every pope has his gifts and this influences the way
younger bishops act,” Cardinal Ouellet said. “One identifies with the
style” of the pope who nominated him and often tries to make choices he
thinks the pope would make in ministry, lifestyle and — especially with Pope
Francis — in ways of communicating; “he breaches boundaries in
proclaiming the Gospel,” the cardinal said.

– – –

Copyright © 2016 Catholic News Service/U.S. Conference of Catholic Bishops. All rights reserved. Republishing or redistributing of CNS content, including by framing or similar means without prior permission, is prohibited. You may link to stories on our public site. This copy is for your personal, non-commercial use only. To request permission for republishing or redistributing of CNS content, please contact permissions at

Original Article