Border bishop denounces hateful words, militarization of border

By Rhina Guidos

WASHINGTON (CNS) — Denouncing
the “demonization of migrants,” hateful rhetoric, the militarization of the border and a system that divides
families, Bishop Mark J. Seitz of El Paso, Texas, called on Catholics
to heed the church’s teachings to welcome the migrant.

In a July 18 pastoral letter “Sorrow
and Mourning Flee Away,” on migration and addressed to the “People of God in the Diocese of El Paso,”
Bishop Seitz, who serves a border community near Mexico, said the country’s
security cannot be used as a “pretext to build walls and shut the door to
migrants and refugees.”

“God did not create a
world lacking room for all at the banquet of life,” he wrote.

He said that while
some might question his reflections, “I am not substituting politics for the
teaching of the church,” but as a pastor, his “duty is to the Gospel of Jesus
Christ,” he wrote. And the Gospel in the Old Testament is clear, he said: “You
shall treat the alien who resides with you no differently than the natives born
among you.”

Bishop Seitz also
criticized a system that “permits some to detain human beings for profit,”
while eroding the country’s “historic commitment to the refugee and asylum

In the letter, he
shared personal anecdotes. One involves a teenager named Aura he met at a
sister parish in Honduras who later decided to make the trip north to escape extreme
poverty and violence. She was caught by immigration authorities and ended
up in a detention center in El Paso but not before experiencing “serious
physical and psychological wounds.” 

She left Honduras for the U.S. because she had been enslaved by a gang and then ended up being treated like a criminal as she sought refuge
in the U.S., the bishop wrote. He also wrote about a devoted Texas parishioner named Rosa,
who in addition to long hours volunteering, works long hours caring for people
with disabilities as well as cleaning houses to raise her family alone after
her husband was deported.

“Aura is your
neighbor! Aura is your sister!” Bishop Seitz wrote, and when it comes to Rosa, he asked: “Who can
deny that our community would be diminished without the faith, hard work and
contributions of Rosa and her family?”

He said moments of
encounter with such migrant brothers and sisters can provide opportunities for
conversion but he lamented that instead, people keep going about their old ways of
seeing the world, with indifference, including an indifference toward God.

“This growing
indifference toward God seems to exist side by side with a growing coldness
toward the poor and suffering, as if they did not exist,” he wrote.

Bishop Seitz said that even
though the immigration system is broken and has not been fixed in large part
because “elected leaders have not yet mustered the moral courage to enact
permanent, comprehensive immigration reform,” migrants should not be the ones paying the

“Still, migrants are
treated, as Pope Francis says, as ‘pawns on the chessboard of humanity.’ Their
labor and talents are exploited but they are denied the protections of the law
and are scapegoated for our social and economic ills,” he wrote.

He praised the work
of border communities in welcoming the stranger, and says places such as his
diocese, are filled with “heroic individuals, families, pastors, religious,
parishes and institutions that spend themselves in service to migrants and
refugees” feeling conflict, hunger and persecution. They also advocate for
“just laws and against the militarization of our border,” he wrote.

As the pastor of a
border community, he said, he asks God to help him console, denounce injustice
and announce redemption.

“I am pastor of a
diocese divided by walls and checkpoints that separate individuals from loved
ones. I am bishop of a flock frightened by the flashing lights of police cars
in the rearview mirror, who wonder if this family outing or that drive home
from work will be the last,” he wrote. “I am (a) spiritual father to thousands of
Border Patrol and ICE agents, who put their lives on the line to stem the flow
of weapons and drugs and those who carry them.

“Many agents are troubled in conscience
by divisive political rhetoric and new edicts coming from Washington, D.C.,” Bishop Seitz added. “I am
a citizen of a community where children worry whether mom or dad will be there
when they return from school.”

Migrants, he wrote,
are not just seeking a better life, “but life itself.”

He asked for
compassion and solidarity with migrants and says the church “must not remain on
the sidelines in the fight for justice.”

To migrant brothers and sisters, he
said: “We stand with you!”

“As your bishop, I
pledge my commitment to stand with you in this time of anxiety and fear. I
promise to hear you, celebrate with you, break bread with you, pray with you
and weep with you,” he wrote. “You possess a dignity that no earthly law or
court can take away. Your families enrich our community and strengthen our
parishes. Your perseverance, dedication and enthusiasm for a better future
renew our hope.”

Bishop Seitz announced he is establishing the Sonador Fund to offer financial assistance to children of migrant families so they can attend Catholic schools in the El Paso Diocese.

The Catholic Church,
he wrote, considers itself a mother to all and therefore no human being can be
illegal in her eyes, he wrote. He
encouraged parishes to become places of prayer, study and dialogue on the
issue, “where Catholics can get involved in the work of building a more humane
border through education and advocacy.”

“We must continue to denounce
the evil of family separation, the militarization of our border communities,
for-profit immigrant detention, the mistreatment of asylum seekers and the
disparagement of our Muslim brothers and sisters,” he said.

He encouraged others
to learn from the work and culture of border communities.

“Our border is
beautiful, rich in history and culture, faith and natural wonder. This is a
place where people of many cultures, languages and nationalities coexist and
thrive,” Bishop Seitz said. 

“I invite young people, volunteers, attorneys and other professionals to
spend time with us in service opportunities available through our many church
and community organizations,” he concluded. “The voice of border communities
must be taken into consideration in the shaping of border enforcement policies
and in debates on immigration reform. Let us reject a mindset of hostility and
work together in generous cooperation for the common good.”

– – –

Follow Guidos on Twitter: @CNS_Rhina.

– – –

Copyright © 2017 Catholic News Service/U.S. Conference of Catholic Bishops. All rights reserved. Republishing or redistributing of CNS content, including by framing or similar means without prior permission, is prohibited. You may link to stories on our public site. This copy is for your personal, non-commercial use only. To request permission for republishing or redistributing of CNS content, please contact permissions at

Original Article