As migrants face a closing door to the U.S., bishops accompany them

IMAGE: CNS photo/Tyler Orsburn

By Rhina Guidos

EL PASO, Texas (CNS) — In anticipation of the 2019 World Day for Migrants and Refugees, a group of bishops, women religious, lay ministers and others interested in the plight of migrants spent the days prior to the Sept. 29 observance listening to tales of hope, dashed dreams, resilience and uncertainty that are in abundance among migrants in this border region.

The daily struggle here does not involve strife between the neighbor cities of El Paso and Ciudad Juarez on the Mexico side, but of keeping up with the policies, mandates and rules directed out of Washington causing chaos in their midst.

Anna Gallagher, executive director of the Catholic Legal Immigration Network, known as CLINIC, admitted to the group Sept. 25 that even she had a hard time figuring out what exactly was happening at the border.

“What I saw and heard these past two days in Juarez … I’ve been an attorney for 30 years and I am confused daily,” in terms of understanding changes in policy and figuring out which communities can be helped, she said.

The newest development is the recent arrival of 1,750 Mexican nationals at the U.S.-Mexico border seeking asylum in the United States after a spate of violence drove them north. The wave came even as Mexico, under pressure from the Trump administration, declared itself a “safe third country,” where Central America migrants can apply for asylum instead of heading to the U.S.

It’s hard to know what can be done because, under the Trump administration, asylum into the U.S., for anyone, seems to have come to a halt.

“This administration has effectively stopped asylum,” said Gallagher.

And there is a suspicion and fear among pro-immigration circles that it’s just one of several programs that help migrants enter the U.S., which soon will face an end.

“We’re very worried about refugees who are stuck in Ciudad Juarez,” said El Paso Bishop Mark J. Seitz during a Sept. 25 news conference outside the Border Farmworkers Center in El Paso.

He was joined by Bishop Oscar Cantu of San Jose, California; Bishop Peter Baldacchino of Las Cruces, New Mexico; Bishop Brendan J. Cahill of Victoria, Texas; Bishop John E. Stowe of Lexington, Kentucky; and Father Robert Stark, regional coordinator of the Vatican’s Section on Migrant and Refugees.

Most have traveled together during a week of visiting various groups of migrants: those in Mexico who have not been allowed to apply for asylum in the U.S.; young migrants with families in both countries; and others on their way back to their countries of origin after losing hope of having their stories of fear be heard.

Bishop Cantu said during the news conference, explaining some of the experiences of the visit, that it was devastating to see the end of the migrants’ dreams, “dreams that my own parents had as immigrants to the United States from Mexico some 60 years ago.”

“We know they’re coming, not to take advantage of this wonderful generous country, but rather to have an opportunity to work and to raise their families in safety and dignity,” he said. “We continue to, as a church, to advocate to our elected officials … for comprehensive immigration reform. … It doesn’t look politically possible at this time, but we continue to advocate for that. It’s the right thing to do to uphold family unity and human dignity.”

Faced with the reality that little can be done in the face of an administration that seems intent on keeping migrants out, the bishops, too, seemed intent on providing the vulnerable migrants the only thing they could: themselves.

They listened to their worries, prayed with them, blessed them, and assured them that God and the Catholic Church, in the U.S. and elsewhere, would remain with them.

And that seemed to be enough for some of those facing the unfolding drama each day.

“We don’t want you to save us. We can save ourselves,” Carlos Marentes, a labor organizer for farmworkers, told the bishops and those with them after they shared a meal with agricultural workers Sept. 25. “Pray for us. We continue to struggle, but we have hope that one day things will change.”

During his homily at a Mass celebrated at the farmworker center, Victoria’s Bishop Cahill assured those in the room that the Catholic leaders from throughout the country had traveled to the region just to be with them, “from Washington, the state, and from Washington, D.C.”

He told them of a Nicaraguan woman he had met in a parish during the visit who shared her immigration story, which was still unfolding because she had not yet been allowed to enter the U.S. with her two children after receiving threats in her home country because she opposed the government.

She wanted to enter the U.S. but was denied the opportunity, and instead found herself alone with no money and nowhere to go in Ciudad Juarez until members of the Catholic Church stepped in to help. She shares a house with other migrant women and together they give each other comfort.

She said even though the journey had been a difficult one, “angels” appeared along the way to help, Bishop Cahill told the gathering.

Those she described as “angels,” the bishop said, would be better described as “missionaries and disciples, people with Jesus Christ in their hearts … people who had the courage to help the neediest.” But the Nicaraguan woman, too, was a missionary and a disciple because she had proclaimed the “good news.”

“Each story is a sacred story,” Bishop Cahill said. “And each story, if we listen, reveals the power of Jesus Christ and the power of the Holy Spirit.”

As the Catholic Church approached the World Day of Migrants and Refugees, the stories heard along the border help to point out “that migrants and refugees are a gift and an encounter with God,” the Vatican’s Father Stark said in an interview with Catholic News Service Sept. 25.

Through migrants and refugees and their stories, “God is providing us this opportunity to deepen our relationship with him and migrants and refugees are a central part of that, ” Father Stark said.

Those who help migrants and refugees talk about how their work changes their lives, he added.

“We’re a church on the move and that church on the move is gaining energy and strength by accompanying and integrating refugees into it,” the priest said.

In turn, those refugees help others, they minister to others and become caregivers, too, Father Stark said.

“We all minister to each other. We’re all wounded. We’re all vulnerable. We’re that field hospital that Pope Francis talks about, where everybody’s wounded and everybody’s called to be a healer,” he said. “Sharing that vulnerability, we become nourished … we encounter God. He offers us this special encounter that gets us moving. that gets us growing, and there we find hope.”

– – –

Copyright © 2019 Catholic News Service/U.S. Conference of Catholic Bishops. All rights reserved. Republishing or redistributing of CNS content, including by framing or similar means without prior permission, is prohibited. You may link to stories on our public site. This copy is for your personal, non-commercial use only. To request permission for republishing or redistributing of CNS content, please contact permissions at

Original Article